Moving to a new state can change much more than your address. It may change which state taxes all of your income, which state taxes only income sourced there, and whether two jurisdictions claim you as a resident at the same time.
That is why a move—particularly one involving a high-income taxpayer, the sale of a business, a large capital gain, or a home retained in the former state—can attract scrutiny from a state tax agency. A residency audit is designed to test whether the taxpayer truly changed domicile, satisfied the applicable day-count rules, and reported income to the correct jurisdictions.
The strongest defense is built before an audit notice arrives. It consists of a coherent set of facts, consistent tax filings, reliable day-count records, and documents that tell the same story.
Residency is not one single test
Most states approach residency through two related but distinct concepts: domicile and statutory residency.
Domicile: your one permanent home
Domicile is generally the place you consider your true, fixed, and permanent home—the place you intend to return to when you are away. A person may own or use several residences, but ordinarily has only one domicile at a time.
Changing domicile usually requires both:
- Abandoning the former domicile; and
- Establishing a new home with the intent to remain there permanently or indefinitely.
Intent matters, but auditors rarely rely on a taxpayer’s statement alone. They examine conduct: where the family lives, which home is used most, where valuable and sentimental possessions are kept, where business and professional relationships are centered, and whether the taxpayer’s legal and financial records are consistent with the claimed move.
Virginia, for example, states that a person remains a domiciliary resident until the person acquires a new domicile and abandons Virginia as the former domicile. Virginia Tax’s residency guidance also distinguishes domiciliary residents from people who become “actual residents” based on their physical presence and abode.
Statutory residency: the day-count and abode test
Even if a taxpayer is domiciled elsewhere, a state may treat the person as a resident under a statutory test. A common—but not universal—framework looks at whether the taxpayer:
- Maintained a permanent place of abode in the state; and
- Spent more than 183 days there during the tax year.
The details vary significantly. Some states count any part of a day. Definitions of a permanent place of abode differ. Exceptions may apply for military service, temporary assignments, medical treatment, or transit. A taxpayer should never assume that the rules of one state apply to another.
New York’s official Nonresident Audit Guidelines, for example, devote extensive attention to both domicile and statutory residency. New York generally treats an individual as a statutory resident when the individual maintains a permanent place of abode for substantially all of the year and spends 184 days or more in the state, subject to detailed rules and exceptions.
The practical lesson: spending fewer than 183 days in the former state does not, by itself, prove a change of domicile. Conversely, establishing domicile in a new state does not automatically prevent statutory residency in the old state if the taxpayer retains an abode and exceeds that state’s day threshold.
How Virginia, Washington, DC, and Maryland differ
Taxpayers in the Washington metropolitan area should be especially careful because short geographic distances make it easy to maintain homes, work, family ties, and daily activities across multiple jurisdictions.
Virginia
Virginia recognizes domiciliary residents and actual residents. According to Virginia Tax, an individual may be an actual resident when the individual maintains a place of abode in Virginia or is physically present in Virginia for more than 183 days during the year. The days need not be consecutive. A person who leaves Virginia but does not establish and intend to maintain a new domicile may remain a Virginia domiciliary resident.
District of Columbia
DC generally treats an individual as a resident if the individual is domiciled in the District at any time during the taxable year or maintains a place of abode in DC for an aggregate of 183 days or more. DC guidance warns that, for its statutory-residency test, temporary absences from a DC residence may still count toward the 183 days. The DC Office of Tax and Revenue’s residency and audit FAQs explain the District’s definitions and exceptions.
Maryland
Maryland generally treats an individual as a resident if the person is domiciled in Maryland on the last day of the tax year. It may also treat a person as a statutory resident when the person maintains a place of abode in Maryland for more than six months and is physically present in the state for 183 days or more. Maryland’s Administrative Release No. 37 discusses domicile, statutory residency, and relevant factors.
These summaries are not substitutes for applying each jurisdiction’s law to the taxpayer’s facts. They illustrate why a move from DC to Virginia—or from Maryland to another state—requires more than updating a mailing address.
What can trigger a state residency audit?
States do not publish a complete list of their selection methods, but common fact patterns that may draw attention include:
- A change from resident to part-year or nonresident status;
- A move shortly before a major liquidity event, business sale, stock gain, or large bonus;
- A high-income return showing little or no resident-state tax;
- Continued ownership or use of a substantial home in the former state;
- A spouse or minor children remaining in the former state;
- Homestead, property-tax, tuition, or other resident benefits claimed in more than one jurisdiction;
- Inconsistent addresses across federal returns, state returns, payroll records, brokerage accounts, licenses, and public records;
- Credit-card, mobile-phone, toll, or travel records that conflict with a reported day count; or
- Information received through federal-state data-sharing programs. The IRS confirms that federal and state tax agencies exchange several categories of tax information, including audit results and return information.
An audit does not necessarily mean the return is wrong. It means the state wants evidence supporting the position reported.
The evidence auditors typically examine
Residency audits are highly factual. The most persuasive evidence is usually contemporaneous, objective, and consistent across several categories.
1. Day-count evidence
Auditors may compare calendars and travel logs with:
- Airline, train, hotel, and rental-car records;
- Toll transponder and parking records;
- Credit- and debit-card transactions;
- Mobile-phone location or usage records;
- Building access, security, and office-entry logs;
- Medical, fitness, club, and appointment records;
- Utility usage; and
- Passport and international travel records.
A spreadsheet created after the audit begins is less persuasive when it cannot be reconciled to source records. Maintain the log during the year and retain the supporting documentation.
2. Home and family connections
Auditors may consider the location, size, value, and availability of each residence; where a spouse and children live; school enrollment; household help; pets; family gatherings; and where the taxpayer keeps items with personal or sentimental importance.
Selling the former home can be strong evidence, but it is not always practical or required. If the home is retained, document how it is used, whether it is rented, who has access, and why keeping it is consistent with the claimed domicile.
3. Business and economic connections
Relevant facts may include the taxpayer’s principal work location, executive office, business ownership, professional licenses, bank and investment relationships, payroll records, and the locations from which financial transactions are initiated.
Remote work adds complexity. The location of an employer is not necessarily the same as the employee’s work location, and residency is separate from the question of where compensation or business income is sourced.
4. Legal and administrative records
Auditors often review driver’s licenses, vehicle registrations, voter registration, property records, insurance policies, wills and trusts, safe-deposit boxes, mailing addresses, and the addresses shown on federal and state returns.
These checklist items help, but they are rarely decisive by themselves. California’s residency guidelines, for example, emphasize the strength of a taxpayer’s connections rather than merely counting how many formal ties point to each state.
5. Social and community ties
States may look at religious organizations, social and country clubs, charitable activity, medical providers, attorneys, accountants, and professional associations. These facts help reveal where the taxpayer’s life is actually centered.
A practical pre-move residency plan
Before relocating, prepare a written plan with your tax adviser and, when appropriate, legal counsel.
Before the move
- Review the domicile and statutory-residency rules of both states.
- Identify any homes that could qualify as a permanent place of abode.
- Model the tax consequences of resident, part-year, and nonresident status.
- Consider income sourcing, not just residency—especially for business owners, partners, remote employees, and individuals expecting deferred compensation or a business sale.
- Choose a genuine move date supported by the facts.
- Establish a system for contemporaneous day tracking.
At and after the move
- Occupy and use the new home as your principal home.
- Update your driver’s license, vehicle registration, voter registration, insurance, payroll, financial accounts, and tax-return address promptly.
- Move important personal property and records.
- Update estate-planning documents when appropriate.
- Transfer primary medical, legal, financial, and community relationships where practical.
- File part-year or nonresident returns consistently with the move.
- Avoid claiming resident-only benefits in the former state.
- Preserve proof of moving costs, home occupancy, and the reasons for the move.
Do not manufacture superficial facts. A credible residency position reflects how the taxpayer actually lives.
What to do when an audit notice arrives
1. Do not respond casually
Read the notice immediately and identify the tax years, response deadline, issues, and records requested. Statements made early in the audit can shape the entire case.
2. Assemble the advisory team
A CPA experienced in multistate residency matters can coordinate the financial facts, returns, and evidence. Tax counsel may be appropriate when the tax exposure is significant, the facts are disputed, penalties are possible, or privilege is important.
3. Preserve records
Retain relevant paper and electronic information. Do not alter calendars or reconstruct records without clearly identifying the reconstruction and its source.
4. Build a master chronology
Create a timeline covering the decision to move, the physical move, home transactions, employment changes, family changes, registrations, travel, and major income events. Reconcile the day count to third-party records.
5. Respond accurately and proportionately
Answer the question asked, organize documents by request, explain legitimate gaps, and keep a record of every submission. If a request is unclear or unusually broad, discuss scope and timing with the auditor rather than guessing.
6. Evaluate the proposed findings and appeal rights
If the state proposes additional tax, review the computation, residency period, income allocation, credits for taxes paid to other states, interest, penalties, and procedural deadlines. Administrative protest and appeal rights vary by state and are time-sensitive.
Common mistakes that weaken a residency position
- Treating the 183-day rule as the only test;
- Assuming a driver’s license or voter registration conclusively proves domicile;
- Keeping no contemporaneous day log;
- Counting days under the wrong state’s definition;
- Leaving payroll, brokerage, insurance, or tax records at the former address;
- Claiming homestead or other resident benefits in the former state;
- Retaining a fully available former home without documenting its purpose and use;
- Filing inconsistent returns for spouses or related entities;
- Ignoring the sourcing of income after establishing nonresidency; and
- Waiting until an audit begins to reconstruct the move.
The bottom line
A defensible residency position is a pattern, not a single form. It combines a real change in the center of the taxpayer’s life with careful day-count compliance, consistent filings, and objective records.
If you are planning a move, have already changed states, or received a residency inquiry, early review can identify gaps before they become expensive disputes. Reckenen can help individuals and business owners evaluate residency, income sourcing, recordkeeping, and multistate filing obligations as part of a coordinated tax strategy.
Schedule a consultation with Reckenen to discuss your facts.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Residency and income-sourcing rules vary by jurisdiction and may change. Consult qualified advisers regarding your specific circumstances.
Sources and further reading
- HBK — State Residency Audits: How to Best Prepare Yourself for the Audit Process
- Virginia Tax — Residency Status
- DC Office of Tax and Revenue — Collections & Audit FAQs
- Maryland Comptroller — Administrative Release No. 37
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance — Nonresident Audit Guidelines
- California Franchise Tax Board — Publication 1031
- IRS — State Information Sharing