A buy-sell agreement is intended to create an orderly process when an owner dies, becomes disabled, retires, leaves the company, or experiences another triggering event. Yet many agreements fail at the moment they are needed because the valuation language is outdated, incomplete, or disconnected from the economics of the business.
A well-designed agreement should do more than name a price. It should explain how value will be determined, who will determine it, which assumptions apply, and how the purchase will be funded.
Why the valuation provision matters
Closely held businesses do not have a quoted market price. Reasonable professionals can reach different conclusions depending on the valuation date, standard of value, methods, assumptions, and treatment of ownership-level discounts. If those issues are not addressed in the agreement, owners may face delay, expense, and conflict during an already difficult transition.
The valuation provision should align with the owners’ objectives and with applicable tax and legal requirements. Attorneys, tax advisers, insurance professionals, and valuation specialists should coordinate before the agreement is signed.
Common ways agreements establish value
Fixed price
The owners periodically agree on a stated company value. This approach is simple, but it fails if the value is not updated. A number chosen several years earlier may bear little relationship to current earnings, assets, debt, or market conditions.
Formula price
The agreement may apply a multiple to revenue, earnings, book value, or another financial measure. Formulas can be efficient, but they may not reflect changes in risk, customer concentration, growth prospects, nonrecurring expenses, or industry conditions. The agreement should define the financial measure precisely and specify how unusual or owner-specific items are handled.
Appraisal process
The agreement may require one independent valuation professional, separate appraisers for each side, or a third appraiser when the first two conclusions differ. This can produce a more current analysis, but the procedures should be clear enough to avoid a dispute about the dispute-resolution process itself.
Questions every agreement should answer
- What is being valued? The entire company, a controlling interest, or a minority ownership interest?
- What is the valuation date? The date of the triggering event, the end of the prior month, or another specified date?
- What standard of value applies? Fair market value, fair value, investment value, or a contractually defined standard?
- Are discounts considered? The agreement should address discounts for lack of control or marketability rather than leaving the issue implicit.
- How are life-insurance proceeds treated? The valuation and funding provisions must work together to avoid unintended outcomes.
- How are nonoperating assets and debt handled? Excess cash, real estate, shareholder loans, and other items may require separate treatment.
- Who selects the valuation professional? Qualifications, independence, timing, access to records, and responsibility for fees should be defined.
Update the valuation before a triggering event
The worst time to discover ambiguity is after an owner has died or the relationship has deteriorated. Owners should review the agreement and the company’s value periodically. A current valuation can reveal whether the agreement’s formula produces a reasonable result and whether insurance or other funding remains adequate.
For many businesses, an annual or biennial review is practical. A new valuation may also be appropriate after an acquisition, major capital investment, loss of a key customer, significant change in profitability, or shift in ownership structure.
The valuation report should match the purpose
A detailed valuation may be appropriate when the agreement requires an independent conclusion that could be challenged by multiple parties. In other cases, a calculation or update may be sufficient for routine planning. The parties should define the required scope before engaging the professional.
Owners should also confirm that the valuation professional has relevant experience and credentials. Business valuation requires judgment about financial normalization, risk, expected cash flow, market evidence, and the specific rights attached to the ownership interest.
A coordinated planning process
A buy-sell agreement is both a legal document and a financial plan. The valuation terms, tax consequences, payment structure, and funding mechanism should reinforce one another. Regular review helps ensure the agreement continues to reflect the company and the owners’ intentions.
Business valuation support
Reckenen provides business valuation services for buy-sell planning, ownership transitions, transactions, and other closely held business matters. Hassan Sultan, CPA, CVA, works with owners and their legal and financial advisers to define the purpose, scope, and information needed for a well-supported analysis.
This article is general information and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Buy-sell agreements should be prepared and reviewed by qualified legal counsel.